Are these real diamonds?

Yes. They are round diamonds, 1/5 carat total weight, graded I-J color and I3 clarity, set in sterling silver.

About 1/5 inch in diameter, a small cluster stud. Some buyers say they look smaller in person than in the photos.

Will the diamonds look cloudy?

I3 is the lowest standard clarity grade, and several buyers describe the stones as cloudy. Expect visible inclusions at this grade.

What kind of backing do they have?

Post backs, the standard push-on style for stud earrings.

Buyers say the style works for male or female wearers. The small size and silver setting suit either.

How do these compare with other 1/5 carat diamond studs?

The cluster setting spreads the same carat weight over several small stones, so it covers more of the ear than a single 1/5 carat stone. The trade-off is I3 clarity, which is lower than most single-stone studs at this weight.

Macy's Women's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling

Best price now

CA$228.00at ModeSensChecked 1 h ago

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit ModeSens

Macy's Women's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling

Best price now

CA$228.00at ModeSensChecked 1 h ago

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit ModeSens

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Price facts

Lowest price today: CA$228.00 at ModeSens (checked Nov 10, 2026).

Our take on the Macy's Women's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling

These are sterling silver stud earrings set with round diamonds in a pave cluster, 1/5 carat total weight. The diamonds are graded I-J color and I3 clarity, and the earrings measure about 1/5 inch across with post backs. The cluster setting makes them read larger than a single stone of the same weight, and buyers call them a good first diamond gift. The trade-off is clarity: I3 is the lowest standard grade, and several owners describe the stones as cloudy.

Best forEveryday stud wearers who want a little sparkleA first diamond giftShoppers who prefer silver over gold tonesSmall ears or a second piercing

Pros

Sterling silver setting keeps the price down
Cluster design reads bigger than a single stone of the same carat weight
Post backs are simple and secure for daily wear
About 1/5 inch across, a small, low-profile stud
Buyers call it a nice first gift
Buyers say the style works for male or female wearers

Cons

I3 clarity means visible inclusions; buyers describe the diamonds as cloudy
Some buyers say the earrings look smaller in person than online
Only 15 ratings, so feedback is thin
Diamond color I-J can look slightly warm next to white metal
Some buyers returned them immediately and would not recommend them

Macy's Women's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling prices at every store

ModeSensNew
In stock
CA$228.00+ CA$41.00 shippingChecked 1 h ago
Visit ModeSens

Macy's Women's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling price history

Lowest price we've seen: CA$228.00 on Nov 10 at ModeSens. Tracked across 1 store since Nov 10.

What reviewers say

4 / 515 ratings

Buyers are split. Several call the earrings beautiful and the right size, and some say they look larger than expected. Others were disappointed: they describe the diamonds as extremely cloudy and the earrings as smaller than the photos, and some returned them.

What people mention

Diamond clarityCriticisedBuyers describe the stones as extremely cloudy, consistent with the I3 clarity grade.
SizeMixedSome say the earrings are the perfect size or larger than expected, while others say they are smaller than shown online.
AppearancePraisedBuyers call them extremely beautiful and say they look great in the ears.
GiftingPraisedBuyers call them a nice first Christmas gift and a small but powerful present.
ReturnsCriticisedSome buyers returned them immediately and say they would not recommend them.

About the Macy's Women's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling

Shop Macy's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings (1/5 Ct. T.w.) In Sterling Silver In Set In Sterling Silver from 950+ stores, starting at $105. Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings (1/5 ct. t.w.) in Sterling Silver Jewelry & Watches Fine Jewelry - Earrings (new)

Specifications

Material: Sterling Silver
Metal Purity: Sterling Silver
Metal Type: Silver
Metal Color: Silver
Jewelry Type: Earrings, Cluster, Diamond, Stud
Style: Classic, Casual
Gemstone Carat Weight: 1/5 Carat (t.w.)

Questions and answers

Are these real diamonds?: Yes. They are round diamonds, 1/5 carat total weight, graded I-J color and I3 clarity, set in sterling silver.
How big are they?: About 1/5 inch in diameter, a small cluster stud. Some buyers say they look smaller in person than in the photos.
Will the diamonds look cloudy?: I3 is the lowest standard clarity grade, and several buyers describe the stones as cloudy. Expect visible inclusions at this grade.
What kind of backing do they have?: Post backs, the standard push-on style for stud earrings.
Can men wear them?: Buyers say the style works for male or female wearers. The small size and silver setting suit either.
How do these compare with other 1/5 carat diamond studs?: The cluster setting spreads the same carat weight over several small stones, so it covers more of the ear than a single 1/5 carat stone. The trade-off is I3 clarity, which is lower than most single-stone studs at this weight.
Where is the Macy's Women's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling cheapest?: At ModeSens, for CA$228.00, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Macy's Women's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling?: Rated 4 out of 5 from 15 ratings.

Stores we've priced the Macy's Women's Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings in Sterling at

ModeSens deals and prices

Gemstone Type

Diamond

Gemstone Count

Single

Embellishment

Diamond, Pave Embellishment

Closure Type

Post back closure

Length

Short

Size

No information, os, Small

Width

No information

Shape

Cluster

Target Audience

FEMALE, ADULT