Carhartt Loose Fit Heavyweight Short-Sleeve Pocket T-Shirt (Big & Tall) vs Harbor Bay by DXL Big and Tall Men's Banded-Hem Polo Shirt
Buy the Carhartt if you want a tough everyday tee that will take years of wear; at $19.99 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026 it is also the cheaper of the two. Buy the Harbor Bay polo if you need a collared, wrinkle-resistant shirt for travel or a business-casual look; it is $22.00 at Poshmark as of November 3, 2026. The Carhartt is the better value for durability, the polo for dress code and packing.
Ask our shopping agent
Carhartt Loose Fit Heavyweight Short-Sleeve Pocket T-Shirt (Big & Tall)
$29.99at eBayObserved Nov 2, 2026, 12:34 PM
Choose the Carhartt pocket tee if you want a heavyweight cotton work shirt that holds up to daily wear and costs less.
Pros
- Heavy 6.75 oz cotton jersey that resists wear
- Loose Big & Tall cut with a 2" longer body
- Tagless neck label and side-seamed construction that limits twisting
- Lowest price of the pair at $19.99
Cons
- No wrinkle resistance; cotton needs ironing for a crisp look
- No collar, so it will not pass a business-casual dress code
What separates them
| Carhartt Loose Fit Heavyweight Short-Sleeve Pocket T-Shirt (Big & Tall) | Harbor Bay by DXL Big and Tall Men's Banded-Hem Polo Shirt | |
|---|---|---|
| Style | Crewneck T-shirt | Banded-hem polo with point collar |
| Fabric | 6.75 oz 100% cotton jersey (heathers are cotton/poly blends) | 60% cotton / 40% polyester |
| Wrinkle resistance | None claimed; cotton wrinkles | Wrinkle-resistant, marketed for travel |
| Pockets | One left-chest pocket with sewn-on Carhartt patch | Button-through chest pockets |
| Fit and sizing | Loose fit; Big & Tall with 2" longer body and 1/2" longer sleeves | Big and tall, example 4XLT with 20-20.5" neck and 58-60" chest |
| Durability | Heavyweight cotton built as a work shirt, a 25-year classic | Lighter cotton/poly blend, no durability claims |
| Care | Machine washable cotton; tagless neck label | Machine wash, imported; ribbed mesh side panels |
Price history
- Carhartt Loose Fit Heavyweight Short-Sleeve Pocket T-Shirt (Big & Tall): lowest $19.99 on Nov 2 at Amazon.
- Harbor Bay by DXL Big and Tall Men's Banded-Hem Polo Shirt: lowest $22.00 on Nov 2 at Poshmark.
Prices at every store
Carhartt Loose Fit Heavyweight Short-Sleeve Pocket T-Shirt (Big & Tall)
- eBayNew
In stockSold by urbanfitwear
$29.99+ $5.99 shippingObserved Nov 2, 2026, 12:34 PM
Also available at
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- legacy-prints.comCheck price at legacy-prints.com
Harbor Bay by DXL Big and Tall Men's Banded-Hem Polo Shirt
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- NordstromCheck price at Nordstrom
- PoshmarkCheck price at Poshmark
Specs compared
| Spec | Carhartt Loose Fit Heavyweight Short-Sleeve Pocket T-Shirt (Big & Tall) | Harbor Bay by DXL Big and Tall Men's Banded-Hem Polo Shirt |
|---|---|---|
| Fit | Loose | — |
| Fabric weight | 6.75 ounce | — |
| Solid color fabric | 100% cotton jersey knit | — |
| Heather Gray fabric | 90% cotton/10% polyester | — |
| Snow Heathers fabric | 55% cotton/45% polyester | — |
| Other heathers fabric | 60% cotton/40% polyester | — |
| Neckline | Rib-knit crewneck | — |
| Pockets | Left-chest pocket with sewn-on Carhartt patch | — |
| Neck label | Tagless neck label | — |
| Sleeve length | Short Sleeve |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for everyday work wear?
- The Carhartt. Its 6.75 oz cotton jersey is built as a work shirt and outlasts the lighter 60/40 polo blend.
- Which is better for travel?
- The Harbor Bay polo. Its wrinkle-resistant fabric and banded hem keep it neat out of a bag, where the cotton Carhartt will crease.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Carhartt, on fabric weight alone. Heavier cotton resists thinning and holes better than a 60% cotton/40% polyester knit.
- Is the Harbor Bay worth $2.01 more?
- Only if you need a collar or wrinkle resistance. Otherwise the Carhartt gives more fabric and durability for less money.
- Does the Carhartt come in true Big & Tall sizes?
- Yes. Tall sizes add 2" to the body and 1/2" to the sleeves over regular, and the fit is loose.
- Is the Harbor Bay white see-through?
- Reviewers say it is. Pick a darker color if opacity matters.