Which is better for making coffee?

The Mainstays. It is a drip coffee maker that brews up to 12 cups in about 5 minutes and keeps the pot warm. The Beautiful is a slow cooker and cannot brew coffee.

Which is better for a party dip?

The Beautiful. Its shallow 2.5-quart pot and low, high and warm settings are made for dips and fondue, and the pot and lid go in the dishwasher.

Is the Beautiful worth the extra $4.98?

Only if you need a slow cooker. At $19.98 at Walmart versus $15.00 at Poshmark for the Mainstays, the two do different jobs, so compare them on use, not price.

Both are basic appliances with plastic or steel housings and glass parts. The Beautiful's tempered glass lid and dishwasher-safe pot are easier to care for; the Mainstays' glass carafe is the part most likely to break.

Can the Mainstays make small batches?

It can brew less than a full pot, but the 12-cup carafe and 60 oz tank are sized for full pots. For one or two cups, a smaller brewer fits better.

Do either have a timer?

No. The Mainstays has on/off with keep warm, and the Beautiful has manual low, high and warm settings. Neither offers programmable start.

Mainstays 12-Cup Drip Coffee Maker vs Beautiful by Drew Barrymore 2.5 Qt Dip and Serve Manual Slow Cooker

These are not substitutes: the Mainstays is a 12-cup drip coffee maker and the Beautiful is a 2.5-quart slow cooker for dips and fondue. Buy the Mainstays for brewing coffee for a household or a crowd; buy the Beautiful for warm dips, fondue and small-batch meals. As of November 3, 2026, the Mainstays is $15.00 at Poshmark and the Beautiful is $19.98 at Walmart, so the coffee maker is also the cheaper of the two.

Today the Mainstays 12-Cup Drip Coffee Maker costs $3.10 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent