Play-Doh Kitchen Creations Set vs Magna-Tiles Starter Set (32-Piece)
Buy the Play-Doh Kitchen Creations Set for a 3- to 6-year-old who loves pretend cooking and hands-on mess-making. Buy the Magna-Tiles 32-Piece Starter Set for open-ended building that lasts years and works for a wider age range. No prices were provided for either product, so compare current store prices on Deal.ai before deciding.
Ask our shopping agent
Play-Doh Kitchen Creations Set
4.7Choose the Play-Doh Kitchen Creations Set if your child wants a pasta-making playset with tools, molds and five cans of dough included.
Pros
- Complete pasta-themed playset with tools and molds
- Five 2-ounce cans of non-toxic Play-Doh included
- Cheese grater, stamper and ravioli mold add variety
- Creation cards give kids easy starting ideas
- Conforms to ASTM D-4236
Cons
- Dough dries out and must be replaced
- Contains wheat, so not for kids with wheat allergies
- Leaves crumbs and needs scraping or vacuuming
What separates them
| Play-Doh Kitchen Creations Set | Magna-Tiles Starter Set (32-Piece) | |
|---|---|---|
| Play type | Guided pretend cooking with a hand-crank noodle machine | Open-ended magnetic building and construction |
| Age range | 3 years and up | 3 to 99 years |
| Longevity | Temporary; dough dries out and gets used up | Reusable for years with no consumables |
| What's in the box | Playset, 2 cutter attachments, stamper, mold, grater, bowl, plate, fork, 2 cards, 5 dough cans | 32 tiles: 14 squares, 2 large squares, 8 equilateral, 4 right and 4 isosceles triangles |
| Mess and cleanup | Dough crumbs; clean by drying then scraping or vacuuming | No mess; tiles wipe clean |
| Allergens | Contains wheat; not intended to be eaten | No food content |
| Assembly | Adult assembly required | Ready to use out of the box |
Price history
- Play-Doh Kitchen Creations Set: lowest $14.99 on Nov 1 at eBay.
- Magna-Tiles Starter Set (32-Piece): lowest $40.00 on Nov 1 at Walker Art Center.
Prices at every store
Play-Doh Kitchen Creations Set
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- WalmartCheck price at Walmart
Magna-Tiles Starter Set (32-Piece)
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- Cullen's Babyland & PlaylandCheck price at Cullen's Babyland & Playland
- eBayCheck price at eBay
Specs compared
| Spec | Play-Doh Kitchen Creations Set | Magna-Tiles Starter Set (32-Piece) |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | 27.94 x 8.1 x 21.59 cm | 11.7 × 2 × 10 in |
| Form | Playdough | — |
| Ingredients | Non-toxic | — |
| Color | Multi-color, 5 colors | — |
| Age Recommendation | 3 years and up | — |
| Safety Certificates | ASTM D-4236 | — |
| Quantity | 5 standard 2-ounce cans | — |
| Packaging Type | Cans | — |
| Age Range | Kids | — |
| Typical Users | Kids | — |
| Theme |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a 3-year-old?
- Both are rated for age 3 and up. Play-Doh suits a child who likes pretend cooking; Magna-Tiles suits one who likes building. Magna-Tiles has no small loose dough to clean up.
- Which lasts longer?
- Magna-Tiles. The tiles are reusable for years, while Play-Doh dries out and the cans run out.
- Is the Play-Doh set safe if my child has allergies?
- The dough contains wheat, and the packaging warns it is not intended to be eaten. Skip it for a child with a wheat allergy; Magna-Tiles has no food content.
- Is the Magna-Tiles set worth the extra cost?
- If the budget allows, yes for long-term value: no refills, a wider age range and years of use. Play-Doh costs less upfront but needs replacement dough.
- Can siblings share either toy?
- Yes. Magna-Tiles works well for mixed ages up to adults; Play-Doh is best for kids around 3 to 6 who can share the tools.
- How many pieces come with each?
- Play-Doh includes a playset with tools plus five 2-ounce dough cans. Magna-Tiles includes 32 tiles.