The Day Sneaker vs Everlane The Modern Loafer
The Modern Loafer is the better pick if you want a leather shoe for work or dressing up, and it is the only one of the two with a cushioned insole. The Day Sneaker is the cheaper, lighter everyday option. On November 3, 2026 the best new price for the Day Sneaker was $27.00 at ThredUp, against $96.00 at Mercari for the Modern Loafer.
Today the The Day Sneaker costs $69.00 less at its best price.
Ask our shopping agent
The Day Sneaker
4.1$27.00at ThredUpObserved at 8:30 AM
Choose the Day Sneaker if you want a low-cost white leather sneaker for casual daily wear and you can try it on first, since many buyers say it runs small.
Pros
- Lowest price of the two: $27.00 at ThredUp on November 3, 2026
- White leather with a clean, tapered-toe look buyers call sharp
- Outsole rubber blend is 94.2% free of virgin plastic; laces and linings are 100% recycled polyester
- Easy to dress up or down
Cons
- Runs small; some buyers could not get their feet in
- Thin sole and flat insole, uncomfortable for long standing
- Slippery on wet floors
What separates them
| The Day Sneaker | Everlane The Modern Loafer | |
|---|---|---|
| Style | Low-ankle lace-up sneaker | Slip-on loafer with tapered toe |
| Upper material | Leather from an LWG Gold-certified tannery | Buttery-soft leather from an LWG Gold-certified tannery |
| Cushioning | Thin sole and flat insole; buyers say it is not comfortable for standing long | Foam-cushioned insole with additional padding |
| Heel | Flat | ¾-inch stacked heel |
| Fit | Runs small for many buyers; toe narrower than other court shoes | Listed as true to size |
| Best new price, November 3, 2026 | $27.00 at ThredUp | $96.00 at Mercari |
| Stores pricing it new | 2 stores | 1 store |
| Grip |
Price history
$1,025.00$11.84
- The Day Sneaker: lowest $11.84 on Oct 30 at Amazon; $27.00 on Nov 3.
- Everlane The Modern Loafer: lowest $60.00 on Oct 31 at eBay; $96.00 on Nov 3.
Prices at every store
The Day Sneaker
- ModeSensNew
In stock
$44.00+ $8.00 shippingObserved at 8:30 AM - ThredUpNew
Availability unknown
$27.00Observed at 8:30 AM - PoshmarkPre-owned
Availability unknown
$64.00Observed at 8:30 AM
Also available at
- EverlaneCheck price at Everlane
- trenbeCheck price at trenbe
- HermèsCheck price at Hermès
Everlane The Modern Loafer
- MercariNew
In stock
$96.00Free shippingObserved at 12:31 PM - eBayPre-owned
Availability unknownSold by great.finds.4.u
$60.00+ $10.00 shippingObserved at 12:31 PM - PoshmarkPre-owned
Availability unknown
$65.00+ $6.49 shippingObserved at 12:31 PM - Vestiaire CollectivePre-owned
Availability unknown
$163.00+ $25.00 shippingObserved at 12:31 PM
Specs compared
| Spec | The Day Sneaker | Everlane The Modern Loafer |
|---|---|---|
| Country of origin | Japan | Italy |
| Color | Black / Navy | — |
| Size | 2, 3 | — |
| Material | 100% Cotton | — |
| Size 2 shoulder | 71cm | — |
| Size 2 chest | 69cm | — |
| Size 2 back length | 54cm | — |
| Size 2 sleeve | 67.5cm | — |
| Size 3 shoulder | 73cm | — |
| Size 3 chest | 71cm | — |
| Size 3 back length | 56cm |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for wearing all day?
- The Modern Loafer, because it has a foam-cushioned insole and extra padding. Day Sneaker buyers complain the sole is thin and the insole flat for long standing.
- Which is cheaper?
- The Day Sneaker. On November 3, 2026 it was $27.00 at ThredUp, versus $96.00 at Mercari for the Modern Loafer.
- Does the Day Sneaker run true to size?
- No. Many buyers say it runs small and the toe is narrower than other court-style shoes. Try a half size up or try it on before buying.
- Can I wear the Modern Loafer to work?
- Yes. The leather upper, tapered toe and ¾-inch stacked heel suit office and smart-casual outfits. The sneaker is the more casual of the two.
- Is the Modern Loafer worth the extra money?
- If you want cushioning and a leather loafer for work, yes. If you just need a casual white sneaker, the Day Sneaker covers that for far less.
- Which is easier to keep clean?
- The Modern Loafer's leather wipes down more easily than the sneaker's white leather, which shows scuffs and dirt faster.