10K White Gold 2 Carat Diamond Engagement Ring vs 585 14k White Gold Princess 2 1/2ct Diamond Ring

The 585 ring is the stronger buy for most shoppers. It uses 14k gold instead of 10k, weighs more at 6 grams versus about 4.75, and carries a higher stated clarity grade (F-G) than the Gold Miner ring's H-I. The Gold Miner ring leads on one point: a single 2 carat center stone reads bigger and more classic than a cluster of nine smaller stones. Owners of high-set cluster rings often note snagging and tipping, so the lower, simpler prong setting on the Gold Miner ring is easier to wear daily.

• Choose the Gold Miner ring if you want one large 2 carat round center stone in a simple prong setting and prefer a lower-profile ring for everyday wear.
• Choose the 585 ring if you want 14k gold, more metal weight and a higher clarity grade, and you like the sparkle of a high-set cluster.