Which is better for storing a riding mower?

The Arrow Elite. Its 72 in walls and 12x14 footprint give more headroom and walk-around space, and the wide swing doors clear a mower deck.

The Arrow Elite, on paper. Galvalume steel with aluminum-zinc plating and a 15-year warranty is a stronger durability claim than the W2505's galvanized panels with no stated warranty.

Is the W2505 worth stepping up to over the Arrow?

Only if firewood storage matters to you. Otherwise the Arrow gives more headroom, better steel and a warranty for a similar footprint.

Do both need a foundation?

Yes. Both are steel panel kits that should sit on a level base such as a concrete slab or pressure-treated platform, anchored against wind.

Which handles snow better?

The W2505 states a roof load of 30 kg per square meter. The Arrow lists no snow rating, so clear its gable roof after heavy snow.

Can one person assemble either shed?

No. Both are large panel kits; plan on two people and most of a day, with the Arrow taking longer due to more parts.

W2505 12x14 Metal Storage Shed vs Arrow Elite Steel Storage Shed 12x14

Buy the Arrow Elite if you want a proven, warrantied steel shed with real headroom and a name behind it. Buy the W2505 if you need firewood storage built in and don't mind a shorter, less documented structure. The Arrow wins on build quality, headroom and support; the W2505 wins on the dual-purpose layout and vents.

Choose the W2505 if you want tool storage and a firewood rack in one structure and a sloped roof that sheds rain.
Choose the Arrow Elite if you want a taller, better-backed steel shed with a 15-year warranty and a lockable key handle.

Prices

W2505 12x14 Metal Storage Shed: $468.00 at Walmart (last seen Nov 2)
Arrow Elite Steel Storage Shed 12x14: $1,846.14 at The Home Depot (last seen Nov 9)
Difference: the W2505 12x14 Metal Storage Shed is $1,378.14 cheaper than the Arrow Elite Steel Storage Shed 12x14 at the latest prices (Nov 2 and Nov 9)

What separates them

	W2505 12x14 Metal Storage Shed	Arrow Elite Steel Storage Shed 12x14
Wall height	About 66 in at the door, roughly 80 in at the peak	72 in walls, 8 ft at the peak
Warranty	Not stated	15 years
Steel finish	Galvanized single-piece color steel panels	Galvalume steel with aluminum-zinc plating and textured paint
Firewood storage	Dedicated side firewood rack	None
Ventilation	Two metal vents	Gable vents
Door hardware	Lockable double doors, no handle lock specified	Swing-open doors with brushed nickel key lock handle
Roof	Sloped roof, rated 30 kg per square	Gable roof, no load rating stated
Assembly	Kit with panels and hardware	Kit, all hardware included

Specs compared

Spec	W2505 12x14 Metal Storage Shed	Arrow Elite Steel Storage Shed 12x14
Color	Gray	Gray
Material	Metal	Metal
Storage Capacity	49 Sq.Ft	1,186 ft³
Length	7'	14 ft.
Width	7'	12 ft.
Height	81.5 in	8 ft.
Wall Height	68.1 in	72 in
Main Color	Gray	—
Main Material	Metal	—
Assembled Length (in.)	164.31	—
Assembled Width (in.)	144.95	—
Assembled Height (in.)	80.40	—

Show all 40 specs

Spec	W2505 12x14 Metal Storage Shed	Arrow Elite Steel Storage Shed 12x14
Product Weight (lbs.)	357.96	—
storage shed dimensions	12*14Ft	—
Product Dimensions	W160.5D139.46H66.46 in.	—
Product door size	W55.76*H65.04 in.	—
Style	Backyard Garden Tool Shed	—
Water Resistance Leve	Waterproof	—
Roof bearing	30kg per square	—
Ultraviolet Light Protection	Yes	—
Assembly Required	Yes	—

W2505 12x14 Metal Storage Shed vs Arrow Elite Steel Storage Shed 12x14

Prices

W2505 12x14 Metal Storage Shed vs Arrow Elite Steel Storage Shed 12x14

Prices

Arrow Elite Steel Storage Shed 12x14

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store