14K White Gold 3-Prong 1/2 CT Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Ring vs Heart Shaped Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Ring
Buy the iTouch Diamonds ring if you want a natural 1/2 CT heart diamond in 14K white gold; it is the larger stone of the two. Buy the Brian Gavin ring if you prefer a lab-grown stone with a stated F/G color and VS clarity grade. The iTouch ring is $1,299 at iTouch Diamonds as of November 3; the Brian Gavin ring is $1,150 at Brian Gavin Diamonds as of November 3.
Ask our shopping agent
14K White Gold 3-Prong 1/2 CT Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Ring
Choose the iTouch Diamonds ring if you want a natural heart-shaped diamond at 1/2 CT with a closed-back, three-prong setting.
Pros
- Natural heart diamond at 1/2 CT, twice the stated carat of the Brian Gavin stone
- Closed-back, three-prong claw setting holds the stone securely
- Full customization of the ring is offered
- Rhodium plating keeps the white gold bright
Cons
- No color or clarity grade is stated
- No engraving option
- Pricier than the Brian Gavin ring
- Pricing is subject to change per the seller
What separates them
| 14K White Gold 3-Prong 1/2 CT Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Ring | Heart Shaped Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Ring | |
|---|---|---|
| Center stone carat weight | 1/2 CT (5 x 5 mm) | About 0.25 CT per the description, though the spec sheet lists 1 CT total |
| Diamond origin | Natural diamond | Lab grown |
| Stated color and clarity | Not graded on the page | F/G color, VS clarity |
| Metal | 14K white gold, rhodium plated | 14K white gold, polished |
| Setting | 3-prong claw prong, closed back | Prong setting |
| Ring size | Size 7, custom sizing offered | Size 7 standard, sizes 4.0-9.0, larger on request |
| Engraving | Not offered | Available with choice of font |
Price history
- 14K White Gold 3-Prong 1/2 CT Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Ring: lowest $736.18 on Nov 1 at Amazon.
- Heart Shaped Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Ring: lowest $1,239.99 on Nov 1 at Amazon.
Prices at every store
14K White Gold 3-Prong 1/2 CT Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Ring
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- iTouch DiamondsCheck price at iTouch Diamonds
- Miraki JewelsCheck price at Miraki Jewels
Heart Shaped Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Ring
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- Brian Gavin DiamondsCheck price at Brian Gavin Diamonds
Specs compared
| Spec | 14K White Gold 3-Prong 1/2 CT Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Ring | Heart Shaped Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Ring |
|---|---|---|
| Total Diamond Weight | — | 1 ct tw |
| Center Stone Weight | — | 1 |
| Diamond Color | — | F |
| Diamond Clarity | — | SI2 |
| Stone Shape | — | Heart-Cut |
| Stone Setting | — | Prong |
| Metal | — | 14K White Gold |
| Metal Finish | — | Polished |
| Ring Style | — | Engagement Ring |
| Standard Ring Size | — | 7.0 |
What reviewers say
14K White Gold 3-Prong 1/2 CT Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Ring
Heart-shaped diamond solitaires draw mixed but mostly warm feedback. Owners like the distinctive shape and the visible stone in a three-prong setting; jewelers and buyers often note that heart cuts vary widely in cut quality and that small stones hide flaws less well.
Pros
- Distinctive romantic look compared with round solitaires
- Stone sits high and visible in the open three-prong setting
- Light, comfortable slim band
Cons
- Heart cut symmetry and sparkle vary a lot between stones
- Small carat weight looks smaller than a round of the same weight
- Prong tips can snag on clothing
Questions and answers
- Which ring has the bigger diamond?
- The iTouch Diamonds ring. Its heart diamond is 1/2 CT and 5 x 5 mm; the Brian Gavin stone is about 0.25 CT.
- Is the Brian Gavin diamond natural or lab grown?
- Lab grown. It is graded F/G color and VS clarity.
- Which is cheaper?
- The Brian Gavin ring at $1,150 as of November 3, versus $1,299 at iTouch Diamonds as of November 3.
- Can I engrave either ring?
- Only the Brian Gavin ring offers engraving, with a choice of font. The iTouch ring does not list engraving.
- Which lasts longer?
- Both are solid 14K white gold, so wear depends on the setting. The iTouch ring's closed-back three-prong setting protects the stone's underside; the Brian Gavin prong setting is open.
- Is the Brian Gavin ring worth the lower price?
- Yes if you want a graded lab-grown stone and engraving. Pay the extra for the iTouch ring if a larger natural diamond matters more.
More comparisons
- 14K White Gold 3-Prong 1/2 CT Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Ring vs 14K Yellow Gold 1.04CT Certified Lab-Grown Diamond Heart Solitaire Eng
- 14K Solid Yellow Gold Natural Diamond Accent Solitaire Open Heart Promise Ring - 2mm Slim Band vs 14K White Gold 3-Prong 1/2 CT Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Ring
- Heart Cut Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Ring in Silver or Gold vs 14K White Gold 3-Prong 1/2 CT Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Ring
- 14K Solid Yellow Gold Natural Diamond Accent Solitaire Open Heart Promise Ring - 2mm Slim Band vs Heart Shaped Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Ring
