Which is better for a beginner canner?

The 23-Quart. It costs less, works on smooth-top ranges, and includes an 80-page instruction and recipe book. The All American is a better long-term buy once you know you will can every year.

Is the All American 921 worth the extra money?

If you plan to can for decades, yes. The gasket-free metal-to-metal seal removes the part that fails first on gasket canners, and the cast aluminum body is built heavier. At $419.00 versus $184.99, you are paying about $234 for that durability.

Which one lasts longer?

The All American 921. Its cast aluminum body and machined seal have no rubber gasket to replace. The 23-Quart is backed by a 12-year limited warranty but its gasket is a wear item.

Can I use either on a glass-top stove?

The 23-Quart is rated for smooth-top ranges. All American says its canners are not recommended on glass-top ranges without checking with the stove manufacturer, because the weight and wide base can crack the glass.

Which holds more jars?

The 23-Quart holds 26 half-pints, 20 pints or 7 quarts. The All American 921 holds 19 pints or 7 quarts. Quart capacity is the same.

Can both be used as pressure cookers?

Yes. The 23-Quart is marketed as a canner and cooker for meats, soups and desserts. The All American 921 also pressure-cooks, and its 5/10/15 psi weight lets you pick a lower pressure for faster cooking.

23-Quart Pressure Canner & Cooker vs All American 921 Pressure Canner

Buy the 23-Quart Pressure Canner if you want the lowest-cost way into pressure canning and you cook on a smooth-top range. Buy the All American 921 if you can spend more and want a canner that will likely outlast you, with no gasket to replace. As of November 3, 2026, the 23-Quart is $184.99 at Amazon and the All American 921 is $419.00 at Texas Ready, so the All American costs about $234 more.

Today the 23-Quart Pressure Canner & Cooker costs $234.01 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent