4.50 Carat Oval Citrine Ring in 18kt Gold Over Sterling vs D'Joy Citrine Infinity Ring

Buy the Ross-Simons ring if you want a big, sunny stone that reads as a statement piece; its 4.50 carat citrine is roughly four times the size of the D'Joy stone and sits in a low, snag-resistant bezel. Buy the D'Joy ring if you want a smaller, more refined everyday ring with zircon accents and a comfort-fit band, backed by far more owner feedback. Both are gold-plated sterling silver, so neither is solid gold and both will wear at the plating over years of daily wear. The Ross-Simons has the higher rating but only 13 reviews; the D'Joy's 4.7 from 146 ratings is the more proven record.

• Choose the Ross-Simons citrine ring if you want a large 4.50 carat oval stone, a bezel setting that protects the edges, and a twisted gold-over-silver shank for dressy wear.
• Choose the D'Joy Brazilian citrine ring if you want a smaller 8x6 mm stone with white zircon accents, a comfort-fit band, and a design meant for everyday wear.