Which is better for a small room?

The Madison Pine. Its 42 in diameter is wider than the flocked tree's 25 in, but it is a foot shorter, so check ceiling and corner space. The flocked tree is a pencil shape that fits tight spots.

Which has better lights?

The Madison Pine. It has 250 color-changing LEDs with 8 functions; the flocked tree has 350 warm white lights with no effects. The flocked tree has more bulbs but no color change.

The flocked tree carries a 5-year tree warranty against 2 years for the Madison Pine. Both are flame-retardant PVC, so care and storage matter more than the brand.

Is the flocked tree worth the extra $28?

Yes if you want a taller, snow-covered tree and the longer warranty. No if you want color-changing lights or the lowest price.

The Madison Pine, with 600 tips over 6.5 ft. The flocked tree has 496 tips spread over 7.5 ft, so it looks sparser.

Holiday Time Madison Pine 6.5 ft Pre-Lit Tree vs Pre-Lit Snow Flocked Pine Christmas Tree

Buy the Holiday Time Madison Pine if you want a cheap, color-changing 6.5 ft tree: it is $31.87 at eBay as of November 5, 2026, against $59.99 at Target for the flocked tree. Buy the flocked 7.5 ft tree if you want a taller, snow-covered look and a 5-year tree warranty. The Madison Pine has far more ratings (13,773 vs 35), but the flocked tree scores higher (4.7 vs 4.4).

Today the Holiday Time Madison Pine 6.5 ft Pre-Lit Tree costs $28.12 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.