Which lid fits a Circulon ScratchDefense 12-inch pan?

The A1 lid is made for that pan and the 5-quart saute pan, so it seats correctly. The generic lid may fit by diameter but is not fitted to the rim.

Is the A1 lid worth the extra money?

Only if you own the matching Circulon pan. Otherwise the generic lid saves about $13 and adds a steam vent and a higher oven rating.

Which lid handles higher oven heat?

The generic lid, rated to 400°F and 428°F with stainless steel inner pots. The A1 is rated to 350°F.

Do either of these lids vent steam?

The generic lid has a built-in steam vent. The A1 lid is sealed, which traps moisture for braising but fogs up.

Which lid has better buyer ratings?

The A1, at 4.7 out of 5 from 2,817 ratings. The generic lid sits at 4.5 out of 5 from 210 ratings.

Are both lids dishwasher safe?

Yes. Both are dishwasher safe, and both use tempered glass.

Circulon A1 ScratchDefense 12-Inch Glass Lid vs Clatine 12 Inch Tempered Glass Lid

Buy the A1 lid if you own a Circulon ScratchDefense 12-inch pan or 5-quart saute pan and want a guaranteed fit with a cool-touch silicone handle. Buy the generic 12-inch lid if you want to spend less and need a steam vent or a higher oven rating. The A1 is $29.99 at Circulon as of November 6, 2026; the generic lid is $16.89 at Amazon as of the same date.

Today the Clatine 12 Inch Tempered Glass Lid costs $13.10 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.