Core Home Fitness Adjustable Dumbbells vs York Rubber Hex Dumbbells

Buy the adjustable set if you train in a small space and want many weights from one pair. Buy the hex dumbbells if you want fixed weights that feel like a commercial gym and last for years. The adjustable pair is steel with nylon-coated plates and a knurled handle, and its 4.8 rating from 159 ratings is strong. The hex pair scores 4.9 from 786 ratings, and owners praise the full knurling, accurate weights and low-odor rubber. The adjustable set carries a 12-month warranty and the hex pair a 1-year warranty, so neither stands out on coverage.

• Choose the adjustable dumbbell set if you have limited floor space and want one pair to cover light to heavy lifts with quick weight changes.
• Choose the hex dumbbells if you want fixed, gym-style weights for presses, rows and dropsets and do not mind storing several pairs.