Agri-Fab 45-0544 Tow Behind Spike Aerator vs Yard Tuff 48-Inch Tow-Behind Plug Aerator

Buy the Agri-Fab 45-0544 if you want a simple, low-effort spike aerator that hooks to any lawn tractor and needs little maintenance. Buy the Yard Tuff 48-inch if your soil is badly compacted or your lawn is large, because plug aeration removes cores and relieves compaction more effectively than spikes. The Agri-Fab has a 3-year limited warranty and 178 ratings averaging 4.4, while the Yard Tuff is a heavier steel unit with no stated warranty. Spike aerators are easier to pull; plug aerators do more for the soil.

• Choose the Agri-Fab 45-0544 if you have a modest lawn, light compaction, and want a wide 40-inch spike pass with flat-free tires and a warranty.
• Choose the Yard Tuff 48-inch if you have heavy clay, a large property, and want true core removal with 32 steel spoons and a wider 48-inch swath.