All About the Dots Sweater vs Chinti & Parker Spot Wool Jumper

Buy the Chinti & Parker jumper if you want a warm, long-sleeve polka-dot knit that will hold up through cold months. Buy the All About the Dots sweater if you want a lighter short-sleeve layering piece with a bolder oversized dot print. The Chinti & Parker has the better fiber story, 90% wool with 10% cashmere, and a medium knit weight; the other is a viscose, polyester and nylon blend despite the cashmere line in its specs. Neither is a fine-gauge luxury knit, so judge them on warmth and print scale rather than softness claims.

• Choose the All About the Dots sweater if you want a relaxed short-sleeve knit with big chocolate-and-blue dots for layering over a tee or under a jacket.
• Choose the Chinti & Parker jumper if you want a long-sleeve wool-blend crewneck in a smaller spot print that works as a standalone cold-weather sweater.