Which is better for everyday wear?

The AllSaints Skiff is lighter and cushioned, so it suits long days on your feet. The Dr. Martens is heavier but holds up better to rough use.

The Dr. Martens 1460 Brogue, generally. Its leather upper resists scuffs and water better than suede, and Dr. Martens boots are built for years of wear.

Is the AllSaints Skiff worth $170.40?

It is a fair price for a goat-leather-lined suede boot with a cushioned EVA sole. Its price history shows it dropped to $71.98 on November 5, 2026, so watch for another dip.

Can I wear the Dr. Martens with a suit?

Yes. The brogue detailing makes it dressier than a plain work boot, and the 7-inch shaft sits under most trouser legs.

Which is better in rain?

The Dr. Martens. Leather sheds water better than suede, which needs a protector spray and still stains.

Do the AllSaints boots run in whole and half sizes?

The listed US sizes run from 7 to 13 and include half sizes 11.5, so most men can get a close fit.

AllSaints Skiff Suede Boot vs Dr. Martens 1460 Brogue Boots

Buy the AllSaints Skiff if you want a soft, lightweight everyday boot with a cushioned EVA sole and a distressed gray suede look. Buy the Dr. Martens 1460 Brogue if you want a tougher, longer-wearing leather boot with a 7-inch shaft and a brogue-detailed upper. The AllSaints is $170.40 at Allsaints as of November 8, 2026; the Dr. Martens price was not given, so compare it at the stores you see before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.