Allure Beauty Box vs B.1802 Beauty Subscription Box

Beekman 1802's B.1802 box is the better pick for anyone who wants a single brand's skincare routine, especially goat-milk products for dry or sensitive skin. Allure Beauty Box is the better pick for variety: six editor-chosen items across makeup, hair and skincare from different brands, plus a member store discount. Beekman owners rate it highly and get full-size Milk RX products, but the box is one brand only and ships every 90 days. Allure's mix changes monthly and leans sample-to-deluxe size, so it suits discovery more than stocking a routine.

• Choose the Allure Beauty Box if you want to try a rotating mix of makeup, hair and skincare from many brands and like a member discount on full sizes.
• Choose the B.1802 Beauty Subscription Box if you already like Beekman 1802 or want a complete goat-milk skincare routine for face, body and hands every quarter.