Portland Leather 'Almost Perfect' Naomi Bag vs Portland Leather 'Almost Perfect' Tote Bag

The Leather Tote is the safer pick for most shoppers. It uses full-grain leather, has both exterior and interior pockets, a key loop, and a choice of open or zippered top, and it holds a 4.9 rating from nearly 29,000 buyers. The Naomi Shoulder Bag is lighter and more flexible to carry, with a detachable chain and an adjustable long strap on the small size, but it is faux leather with one compartment and a magnetic snap. Buyers of both praise the leather look and roomy interiors; Naomi owners note the strap can slip off the shoulder with a heavy laptop.

• Choose the Naomi Shoulder Bag if you want a lighter, slouchy shoulder bag that converts to crossbody on the small size and you prefer a magnetic snap over a zipper.
• Choose the Leather Tote if you want full-grain leather, real pockets inside and out, a key loop, and the option of a zippered top for security.