Which is better for a garage?

The Seville Classics. It holds up to 600 lb per shelf on its leveling feet and has five adjustable shelves for bulky tools and bins. The Amazon Basics is better for light boxes only.

Which holds more weight?

Per shelf, the Seville Classics at up to 600 lb. The Amazon Basics lists 750 lb for the whole 3-tier unit, which works out to roughly 250 lb per tier.

Is the Seville Classics worth the extra money?

If you need height, adjustable shelves or heavy loads, yes. At $78.01 versus $22.65, you get two more shelves and far higher per-shelf capacity. For light storage, the Amazon Basics is enough.

Can I move the Seville Classics once it is loaded?

Yes, on its included casters, but the rated capacity drops to 110 lb for the whole unit on wheels. Take the load off before rolling it far.

How tall is each one?

The Amazon Basics is 30 in tall and the Seville Classics is 72 in. Check your ceiling and doorway clearance before choosing the taller rack.

Do both fit the same footprint?

Both are 30 in wide. The Seville Classics shelves are listed at 18 in and 14 in deep in different specs, so measure your space before buying.

Amazon Basics 3-Tier Wire Storage Rack vs Seville Classics UltraDurable 5-Tier Wire Rack

Buy the Seville Classics 5-Tier if you need real capacity and height: 5 adjustable shelves, up to 600 lb per shelf on leveling feet, and casters for rolling it around. Buy the Amazon Basics 3-Tier if you want a cheap, short rack for light kitchen or garage storage at about a third of the price. The latest prices are $22.65 for the Amazon Basics at eBay and $78.01 for the Seville Classics at eBay, both as of November 8, 2026.

Today the Amazon Basics 3-Tier Wire Storage Rack costs $23.02 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.