StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Opal Hobnail Oil Lamp Shade vs Amber Hurricane Glass Shade 51mm Base

Buy the Amber Glass Hobnail shade if you are replacing a globe on an oil or hurricane lamp with a 10-inch bottom fitter. It is hand-blown opal milk glass with a crimped top, and owners report it fits the frame and matches the old globe it replaced. The Amber Hurricane Glass Shade with 51mm Base is a small pendant shade, not a lamp globe, so it only suits a fixture that takes a 2-3/4 inch neck. On build, the hobnail shade is the sturdier, more specific part; the 51mm shade is a simple cone with a dry-location rating.

  • Choose the Amber Glass Hobnail Oil Hurricane Lamp Shade if your lamp takes a 10-inch bottom fitter and you want a hand-blown American opal glass globe with a crimped top.
  • Choose the Amber Hurricane Glass Shade with 51mm Base if you are dressing a pendant or small fixture with a 2-3/4 inch neck and want a warm amber cone.

Prices

  • Opal Hobnail Oil Lamp Shade: $72.50 used at Etsy (last seen Nov 9)
  • Amber Hurricane Glass Shade 51mm Base: $49.96 at The Home Depot (last seen Nov 10)
  • Difference: the Amber Hurricane Glass Shade 51mm Base is $22.54 cheaper than the Opal Hobnail Oil Lamp Shade at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 10)
A
Amber Glass Hobnail Oil Hurricane Lamp Shade

Opal Hobnail Oil Lamp Shade

Amber Glass Hobnail Oil Hurricane Lamp Shade

$72.50at EtsyChecked Nov 9
See all prices and details
Visit Etsy
Pros
  • Hand blown in an American glass factory
  • Owners say it fits the frame and matches the old globe
  • Crimped top and hobnail pattern suit classic lamps
  • Opal milk glass diffuses light evenly
Cons
  • Only fits a 10-inch bottom fitter
  • 30-day warranty is short
  • Opal white, not amber, so no warm tint
A
Amber Hurricane Glass Shade with 51mm Base

Amber Hurricane Glass Shade 51mm Base

Amber Hurricane Glass Shade with 51mm Base

$49.96at The Home DepotChecked 15 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit The Home Depot
Pros
  • Warm amber glow
  • Simple cone shape suits pendants and bars
  • Dry location rated
  • Small base fits narrow necks
Cons
  • 51mm base fits few lamps
  • No stated origin or warranty
  • Not a replacement for an oil lamp globe
  • Plain glass, no pattern or crimp

What separates them

Opal Hobnail Oil Lamp ShadeAmber Hurricane Glass Shade 51mm Base
Fitter size10-inch bottom fitter2-3/4 inch (51mm) base
Height6-1/2 inches tall, 10-7/8 inch bulge7 inches
Glass and colorOpal white milk glass, hand blownAmber yellow glass
StyleHobnail student shade with crimped topVintage cone pendant shade
Fixture typeOil and hurricane lampsPendants and small fixtures
Origin and warrantyAmerican made, 30-day warrantyNo stated origin or warranty
Durability ratingNot rated for locationDry location rated

Price history

$152.88$49.96
Nov 9Nov 11
  • Opal Hobnail Oil Lamp Shade: lowest $68.06 on Nov 9 at Opentip.com; $152.88 on Nov 11.
  • Amber Hurricane Glass Shade 51mm Base: lowest $49.96 on Nov 9 at The Home Depot; $49.96 on Nov 11.

Prices at every store

Opal Hobnail Oil Lamp Shade

  • EtsyPre-owned

    Availability unknownSold by Seller

    $72.50Free shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit Etsy

Also available at

  • Lowe'sCheck price at Lowe's
  • TargetCheck price at Target
  • Antique Lamp SupplyCheck price at Antique Lamp Supply
Prices and history →

Amber Hurricane Glass Shade 51mm Base

  • EtsyPre-owned

    Availability unknownSold by Seller

    $25.00Free shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit Etsy
  • The Home DepotNew

    Availability unknown

    $49.96Free shippingChecked 15 h ago
    Visit The Home Depot
All 2 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecOpal Hobnail Oil Lamp ShadeAmber Hurricane Glass Shade 51mm Base
ColorOpal, Opal white milk glassyellow, amber
StyleHobnail Student Shade Stylevintage
Size6 inch2 3/4 diameter at base, 7 inch
Product Typelampshade, lamp shadelampshade, lamp shade
Height6-1/2 inch—
Width10-7/8 inch (bulge)—
Light Fixture TypeOil Lamp—
Fitter TypeBottom Fitter—
Fitter Size10"—
Base MaterialGlass—
Glass TypeOpal, Hand Blown, Opal white milk glass—
FinishWhite—
Show all 23 specsShow fewer specs
SpecOpal Hobnail Oil Lamp ShadeAmber Hurricane Glass Shade 51mm Base
Overall Dimensions6-1/2 inch tall and 10-7/8 inch bulge—
PatternHobnail—
TransparencyOpal Glass—
EmbellishmentsHobnail, Crimped Top, Crimp top—
Design HighlightsCrimp top—
Home StyleMid-century—
Material MultiGlass—
Package Quantity1—
Length11 Inches—
CA Residents: Prop 65 Warning(s)

What reviewers say

Opal Hobnail Oil Lamp Shade

Buyers of this shade praise its appearance and glass quality, and say it fits their lamp frames exactly. Several note it looks just like the old globe it replaced, and that it arrived well wrapped and undamaged.

What people mention
  • Glass qualityPraisedBuyers describe thick, evenly blown opal glass with a clean hobnail pattern.
  • FitPraisedOwners say the 10-inch bottom fitter seats perfectly on their lamp frames.
  • AppearancePraisedReviewers say it closely matches the original globe it replaced.
  • PackagingPraisedBuyers report the shade arrived well padded and in perfect shape.

Questions and answers

Which shade fits an oil or hurricane lamp?
The Amber Glass Hobnail shade. Its 10-inch bottom fitter is made for oil lamp frames. The 51mm shade is a pendant cone and will not seat on a lamp burner.
Which is better for a kitchen island pendant?
The Amber Hurricane Glass Shade with 51mm Base, if your pendant takes a 2-3/4 inch neck. Check the neck size first; the hobnail shade is far too wide for most pendants.
Which lasts longer?
Both are glass, so both last if handled carefully. The hobnail shade is hand blown and American made with a 30-day warranty; the amber cone has no stated warranty.
Is the hobnail shade worth stepping up to?
Yes if you are restoring a lamp. The hand-blown opal glass, crimped top and correct fitter are hard to match, and owners say it looks like the original globe.
Will the amber shade give a warm light?
Yes. Amber glass tints the light yellow-warm. The hobnail shade is opal white, so it spreads a neutral, even glow instead.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Thea Glass Shade in Amber vs Amber Glass Hobnail Oil Hurricane Lamp Shade
  • Thea Glass Shade in Amber vs Amber Hurricane Glass Shade with 51mm Base
  • Amber Hurricane Glass Shade with 51mm Base vs Antique Lamp Supply Amber Glass Hurricane Shade

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best amber hurricane lamp shades
false
—
Warranty30-day—