Yellow Mountain Imports Jade Horizon Mahjong Set vs Santorini American Mahjong Set

Both are 166-tile melamine American sets with the same tile size, so play is nearly identical. The Santorini has the sturdier rack setup: all-in-one acrylic racks with swing-out pushers that stay put, and it has the larger review base with the same 4.8 rating. The Jade Horizon leans on its jade tiles and wooden racks with magnetic pushers, but owners say the racks feel rustic and the magnets slip when pushing out the wall. Buy the Santorini for reliable racks and a cleaner travel case; buy the Jade Horizon if the tile look matters more to you than the rack hardware.

• Choose the Jade Horizon if you want the jade-striped tiles and engraved faces that draw comments, and you can live with wooden racks and pushers that attach magnetically.
• Choose the Santorini if you want all-in-one acrylic racks with swing-out pushers that hold up during play, plus the larger track record of owner ratings.