American Trends Packable Men's Rain Jacket vs GB-JA945 Men's Waterproof Rain Jacket

Both are basic 100% polyester rain shells with hoods, and both average 4.2 stars. The American Trends jacket has far more owner feedback (395 ratings vs 14) and packs into its own bag, so its real-world behavior is better known. The GB-JA945 has the more serious wet-weather build: a fully taped inner lining, a Velcro storm flap over the front zipper, Velcro cuffs and drawcords at hood and hem. Buy the American Trends for light travel and everyday rain; step up to the GB-JA945 if you expect sustained rain or wind.

• Choose the American Trends if you want a light, packable shell for travel, commuting and mild rain, and you value a large base of owner reviews.
• Choose the GB-JA945 if you need taped seams, a storm flap and sealed cuffs for steady rain, hiking or windy conditions.