Konges Sløjd Animal Bag Charm vs Bag Charm Keychain Puppy Paw Heart Beads Container Purse

The Konges Sløjd beige puppy is the better-made charm: a soft plush puppy figure in a muted beige that reads as a considered accessory, and owners of the brand's charms describe them as holding up on school bags and totes. The Montana Jewelry & Gifts keychain is a metal keyring with a puppy paw charm, a heart-shaped bead container and a blue tassel, and it is the more playful, more decorative pick. Buy the Konges Sløjd for a child's bag or a gift that should look tidy; buy the keychain if you want beads, a tassel and a paw motif.

• Choose the Konges Sløjd beige puppy if you want a soft plush charm that suits a school bag or a gift and looks calm rather than busy.
• Choose the puppy paw keychain if you want a metal keyring with a bead-filled heart bottle and a blue tassel for a tote or purse.