Mud Master Anti-Mud Mat vs Muddy Mat Super Absorbent Dog Door Mat

The Muddy Mat is the better pick for most shoppers. Its chenille microfiber soaks up water and mud fast, the TPE rubber backing keeps it from sliding, and it is machine washable and dryer safe. The Anti-Mud Mat is a smaller polypropylene and PVC mat rated for indoor use, so it suits a bathroom or kitchen doorway but not a wet entryway. Owners rate both well, though the Muddy Mat has more ratings and more praise for staying put and holding up to washing.

• Choose the Anti-Mud Mat if you want a compact, low-profile brown mat for a bathroom or kitchen doorway and do not need serious water absorption.
• Choose the Muddy Mat if you have dogs, wet shoes or a busy entryway and need a soft mat that absorbs water, grips the floor and survives repeated washing.