Spencer J's Boys Suspenders vs SuspenderStore Striped Y-Back Suspenders

These are not really rivals: the Spencer J's is a kids' clip-on X-back suspender, and the SuspenderStore pair is an adult button-on Y-back in tall sizes. Buy the Spencer J's for a boy's outfit that needs to go on fast and adjust across sizes; buy the SuspenderStore pair for an adult who wants leather button attachments and a longer, dressier Y-back. The Spencer J's is rated 4.4 from 17 ratings, a small sample; the SuspenderStore pair has no rating shown here, so judge it on its leather ends and size range.

• Choose the Spencer J's if you need adjustable clip-on suspenders for a boy, in red, that fit roughly ages through the 22 to 40 inch strap range.
• Choose the SuspenderStore pair if you are an adult who wants 1-inch striped elastic with leather button attachments in a long 54-inch size.