Ariat Groundbreaker Work Boot vs Ariat WorkHog XT Carbon Toe

Buy the WorkHog XT if you need a certified safety toe, a waterproof boot that laces fast, or a resoleable boot you plan to keep for years. Buy the Groundbreaker if you want a lighter, simpler leather work boot for general construction, warehouse or ranch work and don't need toe protection. The WorkHog XT is the more technical boot: carbon safety toe, ASTM F2413 I/C EH SRO rating, DRYShield waterproofing, BOA lacing and Goodyear welt construction. The Groundbreaker is a plain unclassified boot with an oil- and slip-resistant sole and a 4LR cushioning insole, and its 4.4 rating from 425 owners shows it holds up for the money. Both use Ariat's Duratread outsole.

• Choose the Groundbreaker if you want a straightforward leather work boot with a cushioned insole and a grippy oil-resistant sole, and your job doesn't require a certified safety toe.
• Choose the WorkHog XT if you need a certified carbon safety toe, waterproofing, fast BOA lacing and a boot that can be resoled.