Ariat Round Up Square Toe Western Boot vs Ariat Heritage Roughstock Western Boot

The Round Up is the women's boot here; the Heritage Roughstock is a men's boot, so most shoppers are choosing by fit and gender rather than features. Both share Ariat's Duratread outsole and full-grain leather, but the Roughstock steps up with a Goodyear welt, leather lining, ATS PRO and a replaceable Pro Performance insole, which owners say holds up to years of hard wear. The Round Up counters with a lighter 4LR shank and a removable cushioned insole that women reviewers call comfortable from day one.

• Choose the Round Up if you are a woman who wants a lighter, cushioned square-toe boot for everyday wear and riding.
• Choose the Heritage Roughstock if you are a man who wants a sturdier Goodyear-welted boot built for barn and ranch work.