TOMS Astrid Black Boots vs Syren Gulf Leopard Duck Boots
The TOMS Astrid is the better everyday boot: a low 1½-inch block heel, a side zip, and a suede upper treated with Scotchgard for light rain and stains. The Syren Gulf is the better wet-weather pick: a fully waterproof rubber-and-fabric duck boot with a removable memory foam insole and Sperry's Wave-Siping traction. The TOMS has more ratings (4.2 from 46) and reads as a casual, dressier lug boot; the Syren Gulf scores higher (4.9 from 16) but on a small sample, and its 2-inch heel and duck-boot bulk suit rain and snow more than the office.
- Choose the TOMS Astrid if you want a suede lug boot with a low heel and side zip that works for daily wear and light rain.
- Choose the Syren Gulf if you need a fully waterproof boot for wet, slushy days and want a removable cushioned insole.
Prices
- TOMS Astrid Black Boots: $28.50 at 6pm.com (last seen Nov 20)
- Syren Gulf Leopard Duck Boots: $19.95 at Shoebacca (last seen Nov 21)
- Difference: the Syren Gulf Leopard Duck Boots is $8.55 cheaper than the TOMS Astrid Black Boots at the latest prices (Nov 20 and Nov 21)

