Athletic Works Men's Walking Slip-On Sneakers vs Skechers Hands Free Slip-ins Summits

Buy the Athletic Works slip-on for simple errands and short walks on a tight budget; buy the Skechers Hands Free Slip-ins Summits for more time on your feet, a cushioned heel, and a machine-washable upper. The Athletic Works is a basic elastic-gore slip-on with a memory foam insole and a very large owner base rating it 4.5, but it is a house-brand shoe with thin cushioning and little structure. The Skechers adds a shock-absorbing midsole, synthetic heel and instep overlays, a padded collar, and a 1 1/4-inch heel, though its 4.0 rating rests on far fewer reviews.

• Choose the Athletic Works if you want a no-fuss slip-on for quick errands and short walks and you prefer a shoe with a long track record of owner ratings.
• Choose the Skechers Summits if you will be on your feet longer, want a cushioned midsole and heel support, and like that the upper is machine washable.