Athletic Works Scramble Series Football vs Wilson NFL The Duke Replica Football

Buy the Wilson Duke Replica if you want the official NFL look and feel for game-style play; buy the Athletic Works Scramble if you want a durable, tacky ball for backyard catch and practice. The Wilson uses a composite leather cover and carries the NFL name, but its 4.3 rating trails the Athletic Works 4.7. Owners of the Athletic Works praise the grip and how well it holds up; Wilson buyers get a lighter-feeling replica that is more about the look than all-weather toughness.

• Choose the Athletic Works Scramble if you want a grippy, weather-resistant ball for pickup games, practice and backyard catch.
• Choose the Wilson NFL The Duke Replica if you want the official NFL ball look and a composite leather cover for game-style play.