Aurora Roll Arm Tight Back Sofa vs Ashley Monaghan Sofa

The Aurora is the better-built sofa: kiln-dried hardwood frame, down-wrapped foam seats and handcrafted construction in North Carolina, in a compact 85-inch footprint. The Monaghan is the bigger, softer, more casual choice: 98 inches wide, 45 inches deep, reversible cushions and five included toss pillows, and it rates 4.8 out of 5 from 25 ratings. Buy the Aurora if you want a traditional roll-arm sofa that holds its shape for years; buy the Monaghan if you have the room and want a deep, low-maintenance family sofa.

• Choose the Aurora if you want a tighter, better-made traditional sofa with down-wrapped seats in a smaller room.
• Choose the Monaghan if you need a wide, deep sofa with washable reversible cushions and pillows included.