B&P Lamp Amber Glass Hurricane Shade vs Iridescent Amber Hurricane Table Lamp Pair

These are not the same kind of product. Product A is a single replacement glass shade with a 1-5/8 inch fitter, made to slip onto an existing sconce or hanging fixture. Product B is a pair of complete corded table lamps with cast iron bases and ruffled hurricane shades. Buy A to repair a fixture you already own; buy B to add two finished lamps to a room. Owners of A judge it on fit and glass quality, and the narrow fitter limits which fixtures it suits. B is the sturdier, more complete purchase, but it is a lamp, not a part.

• Choose the B&P Lamp Supply shade if you need a clear glass replacement for a sconce or hanging fixture with a 1-5/8 inch fitter and want the hand-cut grape pattern.
• Choose the iridescent amber pair if you want two ready-to-use table lamps with antique bronze cast iron bases and ruffled glass shades.