Baffin Icefield Women's Boots vs Columbia Red Hills Omni-Heat Snow Boot

The Baffin Icefield is the boot for real deep cold: a removable multi-layer inner boot, a 12-inch shaft and a comfort rating far below anything Columbia claims. The Columbia Red Hills is the lighter, more casual snow boot, with a fleece collar, reflective lining and a low ankle cut that suits shoveling, commuting and everyday winter wear. Reviewers of the Columbia call it warm, dry and good-looking, but many say it runs small and narrow. The Baffin is heavier and bulkier, built for standing around in extreme cold rather than walking fast.

• Choose the Baffin Icefield if you face sustained subzero cold, deep snow or long periods outdoors at low activity, and want a tall, fully waterproof boot with a removable liner.
• Choose the Columbia Red Hills if you want a lighter, lower snow boot for errands, commuting and moderate cold, and you value easy on-off and a softer, more casual look.