Baggallini Modern Everyday Shopper Tote vs Poppy & Peonies Everyday Crossbody

Buy the Baggallini Modern Everyday Shopper if you carry a water bottle, a tablet or a full day's gear and want a light, highly organized tote that slides onto a suitcase handle. Buy the Poppy & Peonies Everyday Crossbody if you want a compact hands-free bag that converts four ways and looks dressier. The Baggallini is the more practical carrier and holds far more; the Poppy & Peonies is the better small purse, though owners report a floppy strap loop, a sharp expansion zipper and a heavy feel from all the hardware.

• Choose the Baggallini Modern Everyday Shopper if you want one light tote for errands, work and travel that holds a water bottle and stacks on your luggage.
• Choose the Poppy & Peonies Everyday Crossbody if you want a small convertible bag with a removable clutch for evenings and hands-free carry.