Barbra Streisand A Christmas Album vs Frank Sinatra A Jolly Christmas LP
Buy the Sinatra LP if you want a warm, easygoing holiday record with a full orchestra and choir; buy the Streisand LP if you want a big, theatrical voice and a colored pressing. Sinatra's 1957 Capitol album is the more relaxed listen, with Gordon Jenkins arrangements and the Ralph Brewster Singers, and it includes 'Mistletoe and Holly,' which Sinatra co-wrote. Streisand's 1967 set is more dramatic, splitting secular and religious sides, and this reissue is a 'dolphin blue' colored LP. Both are single-disc Christmas vocal albums; the Sinatra is the safer crowd-pleaser, the Streisand the more showy one.
- Choose the Streisand LP if you want a dramatic, theatrical Christmas vocal album and a colored vinyl pressing for your collection.
- Choose the Sinatra LP if you want a mellow, orchestra-and-choir Christmas record that plays well in the background at gatherings.
Prices
- Barbra Streisand A Christmas Album: $10.18 at Amazon (last seen Nov 20)
- Frank Sinatra A Jolly Christmas LP: $13.78 at BEAST SPORTS (last seen Nov 20)
- Difference: the Barbra Streisand A Christmas Album is $3.60 cheaper than the Frank Sinatra A Jolly Christmas LP at the latest prices (Nov 20)

