Basement Watchdog Big Combo Sump Pump vs Zoeller 508-0005 Aquanot 12 Volt Backup Sump Pump System
Buy the Basement Watchdog Big Combo if you want a complete primary-plus-backup system in one box, with a strong cast iron 1/2 HP primary and a backup that texts and emails you. Buy the Zoeller Aquanot if you already have a working primary pump and want a proven 12V backup with a smart charger and alarm contacts. The Watchdog moves more water and is easier to install as a package; the Zoeller has a better charger and battery management but no primary pump and no WiFi without extra parts.
- Choose the Basement Watchdog Big Combo if you are replacing the whole pit and want primary and backup together with remote alerts.
- Choose the Zoeller Aquanot if your primary pump is fine and you want a durable backup with a strong charger and alarm hookups.
Prices
- Basement Watchdog Big Combo Sump Pump: $467.17 at Walmart (checked today)
- Zoeller 508-0005 Aquanot 12 Volt Backup Sump Pump System: $453.60 at JB Tools (checked today)
- Difference: the Zoeller 508-0005 Aquanot 12 Volt Backup Sump Pump System is $13.57 cheaper than the Basement Watchdog Big Combo Sump Pump today

