BeaverCraft Basic Wood Carving Knife Set vs BeaverCraft S15X Deluxe Wood Carving Set

Buy the S15X if you want fewer, better-finished knives and a way to keep them sharp: black walnut handles, a leather case, and a strop with compound in the box. Buy the 4-piece Basic set if you want the widest range of blade shapes for learning different cuts, since it adds a bench knife and a second Sloyd knife. Both are 20° Scandi grinds in carbon steel meant for soft wood, and both ship sharp for most owners. The S15X has the stronger owner record and the better kit; the Basic set has the broader tool lineup.

• Choose the Basic Wood Carving Knife Set if you are starting out and want four different knives, including a bench knife and chip carving knife, to try several carving styles.
• Choose the S15X Deluxe Set if you would rather have three solid knives plus a strop, compound and leather case to keep them sharp and protected.