Which set is better for dry skin?

A Thousand Wishes includes an 8 oz Ultimate Hydration Body Cream, which is the richer moisturizer. Champagne Toast includes an 8 fl oz lotion plus shea butter, but lotion is lighter than cream.

Which has more items?

Champagne Toast. It has four pieces: mist, lotion, shower gel and hand cream. A Thousand Wishes has two: mist and body cream.

Do both sets include a fragrance mist?

Yes. Both include an 8 fl oz fine fragrance mist. Champagne Toast adds a shower gel, lotion and hand cream.

Which scent is sweeter?

A Thousand Wishes is the sweeter, warmer one, with amaretto crème and gilded amber. Champagne Toast is fruitier and brighter, with berries and tangerine.

Is either set good as a gift?

Both work as gifts. Champagne Toast comes in a gift bag set, so it needs no extra wrapping. A Thousand Wishes is a simpler two-piece set.

Which is better for sensitive skin?

A Thousand Wishes is listed as dermatologist tested and paraben free. Champagne Toast is listed for all skin types. Patch test either one if you react to fragrance.

Bath and Body Works A Thousand Wishes Gift Set vs Bath & Body Works Champagne Toast Gift Bag Set

Both are Bath & Body Works gift sets built around a sweet, fruity scent, but they differ in contents. A Thousand Wishes is a two-piece mist-and-cream set with a warm floral-gourmand profile. Champagne Toast is a four-piece bag set (mist, lotion, shower gel, hand cream) with a brighter berry-citrus profile. Buy A Thousand Wishes for a simple, richer scent gift; buy Champagne Toast for more items and a shower-to-lotion routine.

Ask our shopping agent