Best Home Furnishings Maddox Swivel Rocker Recliner vs Relax-a-Lounger Ellicott Swivel Rocker Recliner

Buy the Best Home Furnishings Maddox if you want real leather, a wide choice of covers and a mechanism you can pick to suit the room. Buy the Relax-a-Lounger Ellicott if you want a manual swivel rocker in brown leatherette and a stated 300 lb weight limit. The Maddox is the more flexible chair: leather or fabric across many covers, a removable back, and power or space-saver options. The Ellicott is simpler and rated 4.3 out of 5 from 28 ratings, but its own spec sheet contradicts itself on swivel and rocking, so check the mechanism before you buy.

• Choose the Best Home Furnishings Maddox if you want genuine leather, a removable back for tight doorways, and a choice of manual or power reclining.
• Choose the Relax-a-Lounger Ellicott if you want a manual swivel rocker in brown leatherette with a published 300 lb weight capacity.