Which is better for a family of four?

The ProOne Big+ holds 3 gallons versus 2.25 for the Big Berkey, so it needs fewer refills for four people. The Berkey's cartridges last far longer, which matters if you filter large volumes over years.

Is the ProOne Big+ worth it over the Big Berkey?

At $49.99 versus $249.99 at eBay as of November 6, 2026, the ProOne is the clear value pick. It is also certified to NSF/ANSI 42, 53 and 401, which the Berkey listing does not state.

Which removes more contaminants?

ProOne publishes IAPMO R&T certification to NSF/ANSI 42, 53 and 401 and claims lead and microplastic reduction. Berkey relies on Black Berkey Elements and optional PF-2 filters for fluoride, without a stated NSF certification.

Which lasts longer before you replace filters?

The Big Berkey: each Black Berkey cartridge is rated for 3,000 gallons. ProOne filters are rated for up to 6 months, so a heavy user replaces them more often.

Can either run without electricity or plumbing?

Both are gravity-fed and need no power or plumbing. The Berkey is 19.25 inches tall and 8.25 inches wide; the ProOne is 22.75 inches tall and 9.25 inches wide, so check counter and cabinet clearance.

Which is better for camping or emergencies?

Both work off-grid. The Berkey is more compact and its cartridges last longer, which suits long trips; the ProOne holds more water and costs less to replace if damaged.

Berkey Big Gravity Water Filter vs ProOne Big+ Gravity Water Filter

The ProOne Big+ is the better buy for most households: it holds 3 gallons, is certified to NSF/ANSI 42, 53 and 401, and costs $49.99 at eBay as of November 6, 2026, against $249.99 at eBay for the Big Berkey. The Berkey wins on filter life and capacity for large volumes, with Black Berkey Elements rated at 3,000 gallons per cartridge versus up to 6 months for ProOne filters. Buy the Berkey only if you want long-lived cartridges and the option to add fluoride filters; otherwise the ProOne does the same gravity job for far less.

Today the ProOne Big+ Gravity Water Filter costs $200.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.