StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Birchwood Casey Handgun Dueling Tree vs Caldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target

Buy the Birchwood Casey dueling tree if you want a self-resetting, moving target for handgun practice at home or at the range. Buy the Caldwell octagon gong if you want one simple, tough steel plate to hang and shoot at any distance. The dueling tree gives you six swinging paddles and a carry case, but its center post is not AR500 and can be damaged by hits. The Caldwell is a single 3/8-inch AR500 plate rated to 3000 fps and 3500 ft-lb, with no moving parts to break. Owners of dueling trees like the no-reset rhythm; gong owners like the simplicity and long life.

  • Choose the Birchwood Casey dueling tree if you want reactive, self-resetting handgun drills without walking downrange between strings.
  • Choose the Caldwell octagon gong if you want a durable single AR500 plate to hang and shoot at rifle or pistol distances.

Prices

  • Birchwood Casey Handgun Dueling Tree: $246.99 at Home Depot (last seen Nov 7)
  • Caldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target: $69.99 at Natchez Shooting & Outdoor (checked today)
  • Difference: the Caldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target is $177.00 cheaper than the Birchwood Casey Handgun Dueling Tree at the latest prices (Nov 7 and Nov 11)
Birchwood Casey
Birchwood Casey World of Targets Handgun Dueling Tree

Birchwood Casey Handgun Dueling Tree

Birchwood Casey World of Targets Handgun Dueling Tree

4.9(17 ratings)
$246.99at Home DepotChecked Nov 7
See all prices and details
Visit Home Depot
Pros
  • Six paddles give constant feedback and no reset walks
  • Tool-free assembly and a carry case
  • AR500 paddles handle handgun rounds
  • Good for solo or two-shooter dueling drills
Cons
  • Center post is not AR500 and can be damaged by hits
  • Rated for handguns, not high-velocity rifle fire
  • Needs flat ground and space to stand
  • Paddles can stick if hit low or off-center
Caldwell
Caldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target

Caldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target

4.6(7 ratings)
$69.99at Natchez Shooting & OutdoorChecked 38 min ago
See all prices and details
Visit Natchez Shooting & Outdoor
Pros
  • Full AR500 plate rated to 3000 fps and 3500 ft-lb
  • Simple design with no moving parts
  • Octagon shape hangs stable from a chain or strap
  • Works for pistol and rifle at any distance
Cons
  • No reactive movement or reset feature
  • Needs a hanger, stand or chain you supply
  • Single target means one aiming point
  • Ring and paint wear shows hits quickly

What separates them

Birchwood Casey Handgun Dueling TreeCaldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target
Target typeSix swinging paddles that flip side to side when hitSingle fixed octagon plate
ResetPaddles reset themselves; no walking downrangeNo reset needed, but no movement or feedback beyond the hit
Steel3/8-inch AR500 paddles; center post is not AR500 rated3/8-inch AR500 plate throughout
Impact ratingRated for handgunsRated to 3000 fps and 3500 ft-lb
PortabilityTool-free setup and included carry caseHangs from a chain, strap or stand you supply
Shooting distanceBest at close handgun distancesWorks at any distance you can hang it
SetupAssembles in minutes with no toolsNeeds a hanger or stand
DurabilityHigh, but the center post is a weak pointHigh; solid plate with no joints

Price history

  • Birchwood Casey Handgun Dueling Tree: lowest $246.99 on Nov 8 at Home Depot.
  • Caldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target: lowest $69.99 on Nov 11 at Natchez Shooting & Outdoor.

Prices at every store

Birchwood Casey Handgun Dueling Tree

  • Ammunition DepotNew

    In stock

    $307.49Free shippingChecked Nov 7
    Visit Ammunition Depot
  • Home DepotNew

    Availability unknown

    $246.99Free shippingChecked Nov 7
    Visit Home Depot
  • Lowe'sNew

    Availability unknown

    $246.99Free shippingChecked Nov 7
    Visit Lowe's
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $246.99Free shippingChecked Nov 7
    Visit Amazon
All 7 stores and price history →

Caldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target

  • Natchez Shooting & OutdoorNew

    In stock

    $69.99Free shippingChecked 38 min ago
    Visit Natchez Shooting & Outdoor
  • Sportsman's WarehouseNew

    In stock

    $77.97Free shippingChecked 38 min ago
    Visit Sportsman's Warehouse
  • MidwayUSANew

    In stock

    $77.99+ $8.00 shippingChecked 38 min ago
    Visit MidwayUSA
  • Caldwell Shooting SuppliesNew

    In stock

    $109.99+ $13.95 shippingChecked 38 min ago
    Visit Caldwell Shooting Supplies
All 5 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecBirchwood Casey Handgun Dueling TreeCaldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target
Target TypePistol Target, Shooting Target—
Target MaterialSteel—
Target HighlightsDurable—
Intended PurposePistol target practice—
Target Diameter49 in—
Target Face Size6 in—
Target Thickness3/8 in—
Skill LevelBeginner, Intermediate—
Age RangeAdult—
BullseyeYes—
Ring Count5—
Scoring SystemPoints—
Show all 24 specsShow fewer specs
SpecBirchwood Casey Handgun Dueling TreeCaldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target
Target ShapeOther—
Target Colorblack—
Target DurabilityHigh—
Target ConstructionSolid—
Target Layers1—
Weather ResistanceHigh—
Reactive TypeNon-Reactive—
Size—13”
Shape—Octagon
Steel Type—

What reviewers say

Birchwood Casey Handgun Dueling Tree

  • 4.9 / 517 ratings

Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 17 ratings, buyers are highly satisfied with this dueling tree. They like the flip-back paddles and sturdy AR500 steel for handgun practice.

What people mention
  • Paddle actionPraisedBuyers say the paddles snap to the other side when hit, letting them keep shooting without a reset.
  • BuildPraisedOwners describe the AR500 steel paddles as solid and durable for handgun use.
  • SetupPraisedReviewers report the tree assembles quickly without tools.
  • Center postCriticisedThe center post is not AR500 rated and can be damaged if a shot hits it.

Questions and answers

Which is better for handgun practice at home?
The Birchwood Casey dueling tree. Its six paddles flip when hit, so you can run drills without walking downrange to reset. The Caldwell gong works too, but you have to hang it and it gives no movement.
Which lasts longer?
The Caldwell gong has the edge. It is a solid AR500 plate with no joints, while the dueling tree's center post is not AR500 rated and can be damaged by stray hits.
Can I shoot a rifle at either one?
The Caldwell is rated to 3000 fps and 3500 ft-lb, so it handles most rifle rounds. The Birchwood Casey tree is rated for handguns, so keep rifle fire off it.
Is the dueling tree worth stepping up to over a gong?
If you want reactive drills and no reset walks, yes. If you just want a tough plate to hang and shoot, the gong is simpler and has fewer parts to break.
Do I need a stand for the Caldwell?
Yes. The Caldwell hangs from a chain, strap or stand that you supply. The Birchwood Casey tree stands on its own base.
Which is easier to take to the range?
The Birchwood Casey tree. It breaks down tool-free and comes with a carry case. The Caldwell is a single plate, but you still need to bring a hanger.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Birchwood Casey Dirty Bird 12-Inch Bullseye Paper Targets vs Caldwell 13” Octagon AR500 Steel Target
AR500
Thickness—⅜”
Mounting Style—Hanging