Which is better for arch support?

The Birkenstock Arizona Shearling. It has a contoured cork-latex footbed with arch support; the Dr. Martens lists only a cushioning footbed.

Which is better for summer?

The Dr. Martens ReWair Josef. Its unlined suede and polyester build breathes, while the Birkenstock's shearling and wool lining runs warm.

The Birkenstock's cork footbed can be resoled and molded to your foot over time. The Dr. Martens flatform sole is a glued unit, so wear shows faster.

Is the Birkenstock worth the extra?

If you want arch support and a winter-capable slide, yes. If you want a summer flatform at a lower price, the Dr. Martens is the better value.

Do both come in medium width?

Yes. Both list medium width and are sold as men's and women's styles.

Which has the better rating?

The Birkenstock, 4.7 out of 5 from 198 ratings, against 4.3 out of 5 from 274 ratings for the Dr. Martens.

Birkenstock Arizona Shearling Sandals vs Dr. Martens ReWair Josef Suede Slide

Buy the Birkenstock Arizona Shearling if you want a cork-and-latex footbed with real arch support and a shearling lining for cold-weather wear. Buy the Dr. Martens ReWair Josef if you want a flatform slide with a cushioned footbed and a lower price. The Birkenstock is the higher-rated shoe (4.7 vs 4.3), but the Dr. Martens has more ratings (274 vs 198).

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.