Which is better for a dog with itchy skin?

The Oatmeal version. Oatmeal is a recognized soothing agent, and Bissell markets this formula as non-irritating and free of harmful alcohol. The Clean & Fresh version makes no skin-sensitivity claims.

Can I use either shampoo without a BARKBATH?

No. Both are formulated for the BARKBATH portable dog bath and are applied through that unit. For a regular tub bath, buy a standard rinse-out dog shampoo instead.

Is the oatmeal version worth stepping up to?

Yes if your dog scratches, has flaky skin or is a puppy. If your dog's coat and skin are fine, the Clean & Fresh formula does the same basic cleaning job with a different scent.

Which scent lasts longer?

Neither is a perfume. Both are no-rinse formulas that clean the coat; the oatmeal version neutralizes odor, while Clean & Fresh leaves a light mulberry scent. Expect mild, short-lived fragrance from either.

Are both safe for puppies?

Bissell states the Oatmeal formula is safe for puppies and dogs. The Clean & Fresh listing makes no puppy claim, so check with your vet before using it on a very young puppy.

Do the two bottles in each pack last the same?

Yes. Both come as two bottles of the same size and are used at the same rate per bath, so a 2-pack covers the same number of washes either way.

Bissell Oatmeal No-Rinse Dog Shampoo vs Bissell Clean & Fresh No Rinse Dog Shampoo

Both are no-rinse shampoo refills made by Bissell for the BARKBATH system, so the real choice is formula, not hardware. The Oatmeal version is the better pick for dogs with itchy or sensitive skin, since oatmeal is a known soothing agent and the formula is alcohol-free and puppy-safe. The Clean & Fresh version is the simpler option for a healthy coat, with a mulberry scent and a short ingredient list. Owners of either report the same trade-off: you must own a BARKBATH unit, and the 2-pack is the practical way to buy.

Choose the Bissell Oatmeal No-Rinse Dog Shampoo if your dog has dry, itchy or sensitive skin, or you want an alcohol-free formula safe for puppies.
Choose the Bissell Clean & Fresh No-Rinse Dog Shampoo if your dog's skin is healthy and you just want a clean coat with a light mulberry scent.

Prices

Bissell Oatmeal No-Rinse Dog Shampoo: $18.99 at Amazon (last seen Nov 13)
Bissell Clean & Fresh No Rinse Dog Shampoo: $24.19 at eVacuumStore (last seen Nov 13)
Difference: the Bissell Oatmeal No-Rinse Dog Shampoo is $5.20 cheaper than the Bissell Clean & Fresh No Rinse Dog Shampoo at the latest prices (Nov 13)

	Bissell Oatmeal No-Rinse Dog Shampoo	Bissell Clean & Fresh No Rinse Dog Shampoo
Primary formula	Oatmeal extract for soothing sensitive skin	Essential cleaning ingredients only, no oatmeal
Scent	Gentle oatmeal scent	Mulberry scent
Skin sensitivity	Marketed as non-irritating; no harmful alcohol	No sensitivity claims; basic formula
Puppy use	Stated safe for puppies and dogs	No puppy claim listed
Odor control	Neutralizes odor rather than masking it	Cleans and freshens coat
Ingredient transparency	Ingredient list and MSDS published	MSDS published
Application	No-rinse, for BARKBATH units	No-rinse, for BARKBATH units
Pack size	2 bottles	2 bottles

Bissell Oatmeal No-Rinse Dog Shampoo vs Bissell Clean & Fresh No Rinse Dog Shampoo

Prices

Bissell Oatmeal No-Rinse Dog Shampoo vs Bissell Clean & Fresh No Rinse Dog Shampoo

Prices

Bissell Oatmeal No-Rinse Dog Shampoo

Bissell Clean & Fresh No Rinse Dog Shampoo

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store

Bissell Oatmeal No-Rinse Dog Shampoo

Bissell Clean & Fresh No Rinse Dog Shampoo

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent