BLACK+DECKER 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker vs KitchenAid 12-Cup Drip Coffee Maker

Both are 12-cup programmable drip machines with glass carafes, strength selectors and 24-hour timers, so the core job is the same. The BLACK+DECKER is the safer pick for most households: it has a far larger owner base and a two-year limited warranty. The KitchenAid adds a spiral showerhead, a built-in water filter and a permanent filter, and it feels heavier and more solid, but it has fewer ratings and a shorter standard warranty. Buy the KitchenAid if you want better water and a sturdier build; buy the BLACK+DECKER if you want proven reliability and easier ownership.

• Choose the BLACK+DECKER if you want a well-proven 12-cup brewer with a two-year warranty, a strength selector and a pause-and-pour feature at a low-risk ownership level.
• Choose the KitchenAid if you want a spiral showerhead, a built-in water filter and a reusable filter in a heavier, more solid machine.