Pino Silvestre Black Forest EDT vs Coty Aspen Cologne

Both are inexpensive, old-school men's colognes, but they smell different and suit different wearers. Black Forest is a spicier, warmer fougère with cardamom, nutmeg and tonka, closer to a cool-weather scent. Aspen is a fresh, clean aromatic fougère with lavender, pine and oakmoss, and it is the safer everyday pick. Aspen has a small but solid owner rating and a longer stated wear time; Black Forest gives you a bigger 4.2 oz bottle and a more distinctive spice profile.

• Choose the Black Forest if you want a warm, spicy fougère with cardamom and tonka for cooler days and evenings.
• Choose the Aspen if you want a fresh, clean lavender-and-pine cologne that works year-round and is easy to wear daily.