Deerlux Black Striped Tassel Pillow Cover vs Ethan Allen Chenille Stripe Pillow

Buy the Ethan Allen Chenille Stripe Pillow if you want a complete, ready-to-use 20" square with a feather/down insert and a linen-viscose face that feels softer and more refined. Buy the Black Square Cotton & Chenille Woven Striped Pillow if you want a bolder black striped look with tassels and a removable cover you can swap between inserts. On build, the Ethan Allen is the more polished piece; the Deerlux-style cover is simpler plain weave cotton and jute, and its own listing says no insert is included, so factor that in. Owners of feather/down pillows like the Ethan Allen praise the loft but note you must fluff and spot clean; cotton covers like the black one are easier to wash but can shrink and wrinkle.

• Choose the Black Square Cotton & Chenille Woven Striped Pillow if you want a graphic black stripe with tassels and a removable cover to restyle seasonally.
• Choose the Ethan Allen Chenille Stripe Pillow if you want a finished, neutral cream-and-taupe square that arrives with its insert and needs no assembly.