Which is better for pet messes?

Product A. Its 3-ply sheet holds up to wet, heavy cleanup and the quarter-sheet tear lets you grab a small piece for a quick spot.

Is the 3-ply worth it over the 2-ply?

For kitchen grease, stovetops, and bathroom scum, yes. The 3-ply sheet resists tearing when wet, so you use fewer sheets per mess.

Which pack lasts longer?

Product A. Twelve double rolls at 76 sheets each is about 912 sheets, well above an 8 triple roll pack.

Which is cheaper per sheet?

Product A at $10.58 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026 works out to roughly 1.2 cents per sheet. No price is given for Product B, so compare it per sheet before buying.

Do both have Tear-A-Square perforations?

Product A does, with quarter, half, and full sheet options. Product B is listed with standard perforated sheets only.

Which has better ratings?

Product A's 4.8 from 19,281 ratings is far more reliable than Product B's 4.9 from 164 ratings.

Brawny Tear-A-Square Paper Towels vs Brawny Tear-a-Square Paper Towels

Both are Brawny Tear-A-Square towels, so the choice comes down to pack size, ply, and price. Product A is the 3-ply 12 double roll pack at $10.58 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026, and it is the better buy for households that want the strongest towel and the lowest cost per sheet. Product B is an 8 triple roll pack with a thinner 2-ply sheet and a much smaller review base, so pick it only if you want fewer, larger rolls or you find it cheaper per sheet.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.