Brooklinen All-Season Down Alternative Quilt vs Nautica King Quilt Set with Shams

What separates them

Price history

• Brooklinen All-Season Down Alternative Quilt: lowest $339.00 on Nov 1 at Amazon.
• Nautica King Quilt Set with Shams: lowest $69.59 on Nov 1.

Prices at every store

Specs compared

Questions and answers

Which is better for hot sleepers?

The Brooklinen's recycled poly microgel fill with 700 fill power equivalent is lighter and loftier than cotton fill, so it tends to sleep cooler. The Nautica's all-cotton fill can feel heavier and hold warmth.

Which one can I machine wash?

Only the Nautica. It is machine washable. The Brooklinen is spot-clean or dry-clean only, so spills and pet accidents are harder to handle.

Is the Brooklinen worth the extra cost?

If you want a smoother sateen shell, baffle box construction, and hypoallergenic recycled fill, yes. If you mainly need something washable with shams included, the Nautica covers that for less.

Does the Nautica set include shams in King size?

Yes. The King set includes the King quilt and two matching shams with two-piece back closures.

Which lasts longer?

The Brooklinen's baffle box construction and higher thread count generally hold up better over years of use. The Nautica's cotton fill can shift and clump with repeated washing.

Which has more size options?

The Brooklinen. It comes in Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, and King/California King. The Nautica stops at King and has no California King or Twin XL.