Which is better for a home office that scans and copies?

The Brother MFC-L2760DW. It has a flatbed scanner and a 50-page auto document feeder, and the Lexmark MS431dw cannot scan or copy at all.

The Lexmark MS431dw at 42 ppm versus 30 ppm for the Brother MFC-L2760DW. The Lexmark also reaches its first page in about 5.9 seconds.

Is the Lexmark worth $60 more?

Only if you print in volume. The extra $60 buys 12 more pages per minute, 300 more sheets of tray capacity and double the memory, but no scanning or copying.

Which holds more paper?

The Lexmark MS431dw holds 550 sheets standard, more than double the Brother's 250 sheets. The Lexmark also accepts an optional extra 550-sheet tray.

Do both print double-sided?

Yes. Both have automatic duplex printing, so neither needs manual flipping for two-sided documents.

Which has cheaper long-run toner?

The Lexmark offers an Extra High Yield Unison cartridge rated up to 20,000 pages, which suits high-volume printing. The Brother is the lower-cost machine up front at $199.99.

Brother MFC-L2760DW All-in-One Laser Printer vs Lexmark MS431dw

Buy the Brother MFC-L2760DW if you need to scan, copy or fax as well as print. It costs $199.99 at Walmart as of November 7, 2026, and it is the only all-in-one of the two. Buy the Lexmark MS431dw if you print a lot and nothing else: it is faster at 42 ppm, holds 550 sheets and costs $259.99 at Amazon as of November 7, 2026. The Lexmark is the better pure printer; the Brother is the better one-box office machine.

Today the Brother MFC-L2760DW All-in-One Laser Printer costs $60.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.