Buff Lightweight Merino Wool Neck Gaiter vs Brooks Dash Neck Gaiter

Buy the Buff Lightweight Merino if you want one piece that works as a scarf, beanie, headband or balaclava and stays warm when damp. Buy the Brooks Dash if you run in mild to cool weather and want a sweat-wicking layer that won't overheat. The Buff is the more versatile of the two, but owners report scratchiness, holes after months of use and shrinkage. The Brooks is a simpler single-purpose gaiter with little owner feedback to judge long-term durability.

• Choose the Buff Lightweight Merino if you want a natural-wool gaiter you can wear several ways and that keeps warmth even when wet.
• Choose the Brooks Dash if you want a breathable, sweat-wicking gaiter built for running in mild to cool conditions.